🔗 Share this article

Badenoch confirmed she would announced that a Conservative government if she becomes prime minister would withdraw Britain from the ECHR.

The decision signals a rightward shift for the Conservative party, who are striving to stem a loss of support to Reform UK led by Nigel Farage. Farage has consistently been a critic of the ECHR and has vowed to withdraw from it if he becomes prime minister.

Badenoch's Statement

Badenoch said recently that she had “carefully weighed this choice, but it is clear that it is essential to safeguard our borders, our veterans and our people”.

Arguments Surrounding ECHR Withdrawal

Opponents of the ECHR argue it frustrates the government’s efforts to address unauthorized immigration and remove overseas offenders.

Some commentators argue that pulling out of the treaty would damage the UK’s global standing and breach the Good Friday agreement, which brought an end to years of strife in Northern Ireland. Russia and Belarus are the only two European countries that are not party to it.

Assessment Conclusions

Badenoch’s decision follows the completion of a extensive study by David Wolfson, the opposition legal chief, which determined that the treaty “imposes major limits on the administration” across a variety of fields, including border control.

The commercial barrister deemed other alternatives, such as revising or opting out of the agreement, “not feasible or insufficient”.

Wolfson maintained that withdrawal was consistent with the Good Friday agreement and the Windsor framework agreed under the former prime minister to simplify trade after leaving the EU.

Party Statement

Tory officials commented: “In contrast to Reform UK, who have made slapdash pledges with no consideration of the implications and no plan to deliver behind them, the Tories have done the thorough analysis to explore the legal and practical considerations necessary to withdraw from the convention in an orderly manner.”

Context on the European Convention

This human rights treaty was established in the mid-20th century and defines the rights and freedoms people are entitled to in the 46 signatory countries of the Council of Europe. It is a key component of UK human rights law and has been invoked to stop attempts to deport individuals who are considered to be in the UK illegally.

Major Issues

Its critics focused their concerns on article 3, which prohibits inhuman or degrading treatment, and Article Eight, which helps to protect the privacy and family rights, arguing that they are being interpreted too broadly by judges and prevent legitimate deportations.

Individuals and countries can only make an application to the European court of human rights once they have used all national legal options.

Leadership Contest Context

During the Tory leadership race previously, membership of the ECHR became a dividing line between Badenoch and Robert Jenrick. She claimed that leaving the ECHR would not solve the UK’s problems, while her rival said his party would “die” if it argued to stay in.